THE STORY IN A GRAPH

Savio D’ Souza (photo: Shyam G Menon)

There’s a graph in Savio D’ Souza’s phone, which has become a milestone of sorts. It depicts his progression during the half marathon, held as part of the 2025 Tata Mumbai Marathon (TMM). Among India’s top marathoners years ago and post-retirement one of Mumbai’s most sought-after coaches in long distance running, Savio finished the 21 kilometre-race in two hours, 28 minutes and 17 seconds. It’s not an exceptional timing. But it is special, for 2025 TMM marked Savio’s return to participating in the city’s annual marathon after a gap of two years enduring an unexpected downturn in health.

A physically fit individual, managing two coaching sessions every day and training and running alongside his wards for his own fitness, Savio was diagnosed with colon cancer in December 2022. The onset of discomfort and the diagnosis were not much apart. The initial symptoms included fever and discomfort in the abdominal area. It appeared to go away with a round of antibiotics. But when the discomfort returned, Savio promptly sought comprehensive medical investigation, following which, cancer was detected. The disease was locally advanced; in other words, stage three. It wasn’t just his colon, the bladder and the prostate gland were also affected. The diagnosis left Savio puzzled at start, for he was a physically active person with a longstanding track record in athletics and who in addition, neither smoked nor drank. Further, if meat consumption was cited as potential cause, he couldn’t help but notice that those into a vegetarian diet also seemed to develop the disease. “ I couldn’t figure out why I got cancer,’’ he said. On the bright side, likely due to his physically active lifestyle, Savio didn’t have any comorbidities.

Following the diagnosis, Savio resolved to follow whatever his doctors advised. He temporarily handed over the training responsibilities for his group of runners – Savio Stars (the group was commenced in 2005, the second year of the Mumbai marathon) – to Dev Raman, a senior runner. Raman was assisted by Savio’s deputies. That done, Savio embraced medical treatment. In all, Savio had 12 sessions of chemotherapy and five of radiation. The main hospital involved in treating him was Mumbai’s Tata Memorial Hospital, reputed for its cancer care. For six of the chemotherapy sessions, Savio visited Sir HN Reliance Foundation Hospital and Research Centre as well. Asked if he experienced any weakness during the period of chemotherapy, Savio said that aside from occasional blisters in the mouth, he was generally okay. He didn’t feel particularly tired or drained out. For both accessing medical care and staying positive through the treatment phase, the running community and in particular, Savio Stars, were of considerable help. In Mumbai, the typical running ecosystem featuring a large group of runners under a coach, is a small cross section of life’s essentials. Doctors who are into running were always at hand to help Savio understand test results, treatment protocols and recommend the best options in health care.

When battling cancer, a positive frame of mind is very important. Chemotherapy and radiation have the tendency of lowering the body’s capacity to defend against infections. Savio was instructed to stay off crowded places. He diligently maintained this approach for the first round of chemotherapy. Rose, Savio’s wife, used to the athlete’s ways, realized that keeping Savio indoors for long would dampen his spirits. So, on some days, his trainees out on their morning run would come by and Savio would go with a few of them to a secluded corner of the beach that was devoid of crowds, for a brief walk. He wore a mask. On July 6, 2023, after nine sessions of chemotherapy were completed, Savio underwent surgery. A part of the colon and the whole bladder, were removed. Post-surgery, the doctors had special plastic bags attached externally to his body, which collected the body’s solid and liquid waste products. He spent 13 days in hospital for the surgery. Recovery wasn’t exactly a simple path. There was a procedure endured later, in March 2024, to remove the plastic bag for solid waste, reverse that temporary method for waste evacuation and restore the patient’s ability to use the toilet. Given Savio’s bladder has been removed, the plastic bag for collecting urine will remain a permanent adjunct.

There were two moments of anxiety in the recuperation phase. Once, a block developed in the waste evacuation process causing acute discomfort. It brought Savio back to hospital briefly. The other moment of anxiety has a backdrop in physical activity to it. During these months of tackling cancer and recovering from it, Savio had his cataract operations also done. Towards the end of August 2024, he commenced a slow return to his coaching activity. He was very cautious; there was the post-surgery (cancer surgery) care to be cognisant of and cataract procedure recently done meant his eyes too had to be shielded from Mumbai’s rain. There was no more of that old Savio trait of showing his wards how to do their training. Instead, he would be present for the training sessions to oversee them and also use the time he had on the city’s Marine Drive to first walk slowly and then progressively intersperse those walks with short blends of walking and jogging. Once during this phase, he developed a small niggle in his lower back and resorting to old habit, he used a foam roller at home to address it. Not long thereafter, he found traces of blood in his urine. The doctors have since told him to completely stay off any such movements or any exercise that may strain his abdominal area (so, no planks for this runner). Meanwhile, at his training sessions on Marine Drive, which he attended in the morning (at the time of writing, Savio hadn’t yet begun attending the evening sessions), the coach kept gently nudging up the share of those run-walk blends in his walking. As he put it, even in pre-cancer days, he was always one recommending a gradual ramping up of training for his wards. “ I believe in taking things slow. Many amateur runners, when they enlist for training with me, are revisiting running after a long gap. Some of them haven’t run for years. Ramping up fast causes needless injury. Therefore, in the early stages of training, I tell them to come for the training sessions and simply walk. After all, serious training makes sense only if your body is first acquainted to those early morning hours,’’ Savio said. Post cancer, that gradual easing into running became the coach’s advice to his own self.

For this author, untutored in medicine, the conversation with Savio left a couple of points to reflect on. The first was the late detection of cancer. Is it a pattern seen in physically fit people that their fitness, general robustness and higher tolerance of pain, delays detection of things gone wrong? And if late detection is a trend, then would periodic medical check-ups be the relevant way forward for the physical fit? The second question was an often posed one – if diseases can set in despite investment in physical fitness, then what exactly is the benefit of trying to be physically fit? This blog met Dr Rajat Chauhan for the first time in August 2011, at the second edition of La Ultra The High, the iconic ultramarathon, once held every year in Ladakh. A specialist in sports and exercise medicine, he is also a columnist, a longstanding ultrarunner and the founder-race director of La Ultra The High. According to Dr Chauhan, there is no one-size-fits-all template or paradigm to answer the first question. To begin with the whole question of why somebody gets a disease is explicable to some extent and a grey area to some extent. A popular example would be the condition of having fatty liver disease. There was a time when it was associated with alcoholics. Now it is seen as a lifestyle disease affecting more those who don’t consume alcohol. Similarly, within the realm of certain body types generally spoken of as linked to improved well-being, smaller details count. For instance, an overweight but physically active person may be better off than a thin, physically inactive sort. In other words, merely because one is thin, one needn’t be healthier. Viewed so, there is a lot in health that is specific to the individual. Assigning general parameters could be misleading. As for detection – as much as a superior level of physical fitness may be argued to delay detection of diseases in the physically fit, it is equally possible that given individuals who exercise regularly or live the physically active life, have a better connection to their body, they may report anomalies earlier.

Specifically on colon cancer, Dr Chauhan pointed out that it isn’t usually among conditions detected early. The best bet we have against cancer at large is a good quality of life; sleeping well, preserving good mental health, having good eating habits and remaining physically active would be among the ingredients going into it. The problem with periodic health check-ups for the physically active as a general precaution to avoid late detection of diseases is that many of the diseases and conditions which visit us, typically require a detailed medical examination to show up. In other words, a general medical check-up needn’t guarantee all problems showing up. Under the system of healthcare currently available, medical check-ups are expensive. So, if one establishes periodic check-ups as the main relevant alternative for the physically fit to avoid late detection, then it could well end up as money spent to keep the healthcare system healthy rather than oneself healthy. Or consider for example, tests around joint health and mobility conducted on all who have reported for a marathon. “ Investigations like MRI done for the spine and knee, done on most of the runners as well as non-runners, would show abnormalities. Out of which, 90 per cent or more would have no symptoms whatsoever. But based on those findings, they could either be told by my colleagues that they should stop running, or their well-meaning family and friends could tell them the same too. Also, if there is back or knee pain, we need to address it smartly, when their sense of both mental and physical well-being, is rooted in running. What counts more – is it that well-being and joints still usable because of activity, or a cessation of the activity that they are in love with? Most runners, and even other sport enthusiasts end up coming to me because their other doctors have told them to stop playing the sport that defines them. It’s like a death sentence for them,” Dr Chauhan wrote in (this blog’s interaction with him was via a mix of telephonic conversation and email). Having said that, some basic medical evaluation done periodically does make sense for a general idea of where one stands.

With regard to the relevance of investing in physical fitness amidst ailments happening to even the physically fit, Dr Chauhan agreed that one of the benefits of a physically active lifestyle is reduced comorbidities. He recalled an extensive study done during the COVID-19 period in New York, which showed that those into a physically active lifestyle diagnosed with COVID-19, had milder infection or spent less time in the hospital to recover. And yet, despite the availability of such bullet points to underscore the relevance of being physically active, the most tangible justification for physical activity is that it makes people feel good about themselves in the time they are alive. On a philosophic note, Dr Chauhan admitted to wondering – “ why don’t we focus on adding more life to years than only thinking about adding years to life at any cost?’’               

Back on Marine Drive, as 2024 entered its final months, Savio tested his post-operation fitness patiently through several days of walking and doing that blend of walking and running. Thanks to two years without any significant physical activity, there was a slump in cardiovascular fitness to overcome. As well as get them limbs moving smoothly like before. Eventually, the 71-year-old sensed his body sending a green signal for the idea he had in mind – take part in Mumbai’s annual marathon. In November 2024, Savio decided to register for the 2025 TMM in the half marathon category. The event’s organizers accommodated the late request from one of the city’s most loved coaches. Savio’s long runs in the run up to the half marathon of January 19, 2025, were just two – both of 10 kilometres each. He deemed that enough for he had been doing regular run-walk of shorter distances, had loads of experience in running from the past to dig into and his immediate goal was anyway to just complete the race. In his pre-cancer days, he was used to running long without much hydration. Post surgery, the doctors had told him to hydrate properly including at TMM. Missing a bladder, he would be running with that plastic bag meant to collect urine as it formed. “ The only issue was whether the plastic bag may flap around as I run. But that never happened during the race because I have a smooth, running style. One that doesn’t disturb the bag. And if at all the bag gets moved around, I can tuck it under the elastic of my shorts; it stays in place. Besides, every time I visited a loo along the marathon’s course, I was quicker than the average runner at finishing my business and coming off. I just have to empty my bag!’’ Savio said laughing.

Five days after 2025 TMM, at their apartment near Mumbai’s Metro cinema, Savio and Rose were a picture of happiness as they shared that graph. As mentioned, the time taken to finish was 2:28:17. Savio placed tenth out of 67 runners in his age category of 70 years and above for men. What made him love the graph, was the pattern of progression. Till around 6.5 kilometres in the race, it shows him maintaining a steady pace of seven minutes and 20 seconds to cover a kilometre. Then, over the next 10 kilometres, he turns up the pace, not ascending to dramatically high levels, but a comfortable peak of seven minutes. After that, it gently eases to a finish at around seven minutes and five seconds. In other words, tiny increments held steadily for long. “ You understood?’’ Savio asked me. I didn’t, initially. “ No, he didn’t,’’ Rose said from the side. The coach explained it again, patiently. I got it.

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai)

MARATHON IN INDIA / WANTED: A BIG PUSH

Illustration: Shyam G Menon

As we enter another winter season and along with it, the annual bloom of city marathons, it would be good to remember that performance-wise, the marathon in India is stuck.

Shivnath Singh’s national record of two hours and 12 minutes in the marathon, set at an event in Jalandhar in 1978, continues intact. It is the longest surviving national record. The closest an Indian got to it was in 2022, when T. Gopi clocked 2:13:39 at the year’s Seoul Marathon. Thereafter, the lull in progression has been thick enough to cut with a knife. Following the failure of its athletes to meet the qualifying time, India did not have a marathon runner at the last Olympic Games. Top athletes have pointed out in conversations with this blog that while 2:12:00 remains a major milestone to cross in the Indian marathon scene, when juxtaposed on the global scenario, it is nothing. The late Kelvin Kiptum’s world record in the men’s marathon stands at 2:00:35.

Alongside, and even as the number of marathons in India has increased considerably over the years, the interest shown by the nation’s sports administration in the discipline has declined. The decline mentioned is not in terms of the support expected to be provided. It is with regard to how the marathon is perceived in the pantheon of disciplines administrators periodically scan to decide which item merits attention. Right now, what one gathers is that within Indian sports administration, the marathon is not a matter of urgency. It has slipped. And it is a strange predicament for this side and that of 42.195 kilometers, improvement appears good enough to warrant support and enthusiasm for those distances. Compared to Shivnath Singh’s national record surviving unchallenged for 46 years, records have been rewritten in disciplines in running up to 10,000m and past 42.195 kilometers.

A brief conversation this blog had with a top Indian sports administrator in December 2024, hinted at how the establishment thinks with regard to the marathon. Although about 42.195 and what Shivnath Singh’s national record still reigning unbroken meant for the marathon in India, the conversation unfailingly touched upon Avinash Sable. Sable has been a phenomenon; a one-man powerhouse in Indian athletics. He rehauled the national record in the men’s 3000m steeplechase several times, featured in the finals of top international competitions and also holds the national record in the men’s half marathon. Sable is among India’s greatest athletes. Although a lot happens when the distance to run is doubled and likening the half to the full marathon is incorrect, Sable’s 2020 national record in the half marathon – 1:00:30 – is less distant from Yomif Kejelcha’s 2024 world record (pending ratification) of 57 minutes and 30 seconds, than the best Indian timing in the full marathon is from the corresponding world record. On the other side of 42.195 kilometers, Indians have rather quickly carved out an impression at the Asian level in the ultramarathon. The overall standing is still hinged to the luxury of having team championships and how a few key ultrarunners deliver but Indian teams have finished on the podium and a handful of international events – ranging from Asia-Oceania championships to world championships – have been held in India.

Following mention of Sable, the administrator quickly veered to the promise seen in the middle to early long distances. The athlete spoken of was Gulveer Singh. In November, at the 2024 Hachioji Long Distance athletics meet in Japan, the 26-year-old had improved his own national record in the 10,000 meters from 27 minutes, 41.81 seconds to 27:14.88. The approach to answering the question indicated the current focus in distance running being on disciplines leading up to the marathon. Performance in the marathon, this blog was told, was expected to be shaped through the interest shown in it by the Indian Army (the Army Sports Institute [ASI] was cited as a nodal player in this context) and interventions by private sports bodies like those associated with Reliance and JSW. There was also a second half in the overall view and it comprised of two points. First, the administrator found it unfair that the current sports ecosystem ran on an architecture of the government investing to do the hard work of finding talent while the private agencies ran with the cream of the talent the government groomed, developed it further and cornered credits accruing thereafter. Second, the administrator felt that the top Indian marathoners were running too many races to get prize money instead of rationing their participation in events.

A portrait of them as people who run for money didn’t sit well with the elite athletes this blog spoke to. First, according to them, they don’t participate in a lot of races. From what one could gather, speaking to elite athletes, right now there is no national camp for the marathon. Those from the army train at the ASI in Pune, Sports Authority of India (SAI) in Bengaluru and at camps managed by themselves in Ooty. There is a foreign coach at the ASI. And for those additionally supported by private sports agencies, there is the scope to participate in races overseas or train overseas provided the acceptance abroad and the paperwork for the same are readied by the athlete. Second, the athletes feel they can’t be blamed for a marathon ecosystem, which features prize money. Even the international marathon ecosystem has races with prize money and many of the star athletes finishing high in the Olympics take part in these races.

From what this blog could decipher based on its conversations with elite athletes and its reservoir of conversations with civilian runners and those involved with the Indian running ecosystem, there are probably two areas requiring attention to get the marathon in India back on its feet. First, there is merit in the interest shown in the middle to early long distances. These largely track distances have served globally as the cradle from which, talent for the longer distances emerge. Further, one of the complaints often heard from elite Indian athletes running the 42.195, is of them doing well till the mid-30 kilometres or so and then finding it hard to sustain the targeted pace. They don’t seem to have figured out yet why this is happening and they have looked at inputs ranging from diet to strength training and mileage. This likely underscores the potential in the middle to early long distances and up to the half marathon; it also shows work still to be done in the 42.195. As one elite runner pointed out, “ it is tempting to ascribe our weakness to genetics but look at Japan – they may not be winning the medals at elite races but they have more people capable of timings less than two hours and 15 minutes in the marathon than India does. So, there can be no excuses.’’ It speaks something about running ecosystems overseas and the need to examine their Indian equivalent to know where we are getting it wrong. This is the second of the two areas for study mentioned earlier – the ecosystem.

Illustration: Shyam G Menon

The number of road races have been slowly growing in India. According to Venkatraman Pichumani of RaceMart, India now hosts almost 2000 road races every year. Thanks mainly to them, the number of recreational runners has risen manifold. Elite runners participate in a few of these events. The vast majority of these races is powered by civilian runners, including those from their ranks who run well. A couple of aspects mark this category as different from the elites. The typical elite athlete – reference herein being to those from the army – trains twice a day; in the morning and in the evening. Given they are army personnel, they enjoy consistent salary even if their job is to dedicate themselves to sports. The reality of amateurs is different. Most of them work at regular jobs, which are rarely empathetic to pursuits irrelevant to given line of work. Training twice a day can be difficult both for want of time and want of official acceptance. Amateurs train on their own. Some of them train with civilian coaches who have had a long tenure in distance running either as civilian athletes or athletes in the military. This blog has come across coaches with promising wards who wish there was some means by which, the talent they groomed as best as they could, may be helped along to the next level of training with marathon elites. Such link is not easily found. In principle, civilians in big cities and big states are better off in establishing these connections because they live in locales with systems in place. Even then, linking to elite camps is tough. When you hail from less economically developed circumstances, the chances are dismal. A woman marathon runner, who hails from a comparatively remote region and represented India once, said that for her event abroad she trained alone. On the other hand, training in a group is an integral part of the marathon. The reason, as a leading civilian coach explained, is simple – the chore of maintaining a targeted pace for long or piling on mileage becomes less boring. Right now, in India, the best marathon runners appear to be in two distinct camps. The military runners train in their own group. The best civilian runners train on their own. Civilians also don’t seem to be in groups of equally competent runners as in the army. Not just that – when you don’t know what fetches the establishment’s attention, you end up running several events hoping somebody will notice you and recommend you for higher levels of training. Of the earlier mentioned woman marathoner, her coach said, “ she ran and ran and they kept saying the timing wasn’t good enough. How would she improve her timing when where she hailed from had no modern training facility at that point in time?’’ Indications are – it is time we broke this pattern.

In spite of the limitations they face, civilian athletes from India have improved their performance. Slowly, there is a pool of talent beginning to develop just this side and that of the two hours, 20 minutes-mark in the men’s marathon. Yet strangely, one couldn’t find in the marathon circuit, any talk of training camps – virtual or real – that brought together the best of civilians and the best from the army. No drift towards a larger pool of talent focused on the simplest of challenges to improve India’s performance in the marathon – taking down that longstanding national record. To give one example: in a training camp featuring the best from both army and civilian backdrops, athletes get an opportunity to learn from each other. This is however easier said than done. First, the army runners are far ahead in terms of timing. Second, in India the civilian-military divide is such that shared spaces are rare. Still, at least one elite athlete this blog spoke to said that provided discipline and focus are maintained in the spaces shared, athletes of high calibre, irrespective of their background, will always be useful as partners to train with and maintain a targeted pace. Doing so, people get pushed; everyone learns. The pool for selectors to pick from, grows. This blog spoke to a civilian runner with personal best in the range of two hours, 18 minutes in the marathon for his view. Years ago, as a 10,000m runner, he had the good fortune of being in the national camp and training with elites from the military. As a marathoner, despite good timing by Indian civilian standards, he hasn’t been called for any national camp. “ It is not easy. On the other hand, ten good athletes training together will produce one or two who will inch closer to 2:12:00. It will take some time, but it will happen,’’ he said. Former national level marathoner and Mumbai-based coach, Savio D’Souza, recalled this compartmentalized life wasn’t the case earlier. “ In 1986, I was at the national camp in Patiala training for the marathon along with runners from the military,’’ he said.

An easy way to facilitate a convergent atmosphere, at least occasionally, without talking of training camps, is to hold periodic trials that bring together the best from military and civilians. An invite to such trials would be treasured; civilians would see it as an honour. When this blog asked the earlier mentioned sport administrator whether officialdom favoured dedicated Olympic trials in the marathon where the best from the army and civilian ranks participated, the reply was: one can already do that in any of the annual editions of the Mumbai Marathon or the National Marathon held in Delhi. The reply amazed because neither of these events are spoken of by runners as having a course or weather conditions ideal for record breaking performance. And this is without mentioning the fact that civic authorities in India are yet to grasp how much of a difference good roads make to popularizing a road running event (a societal wish to respect running and love the fact that one’s city has a marathon, eludes India). On the other hand, trials to select runners for major events can be anywhere having a good course, conducive weather conditions and the capacity to support a race at a given point in time. It can be offered by the establishment as an additional option to qualify, not to mention – allow for a fraternity of elite athletes driven by sport and not separated by walls. Still, to be fair, can one convincingly counter what the senior sport administrator said? The answer is no. And that is because elite athletes from overseas, running at Indian events, have shown repeatedly that timings better than what Indian elites deliver is possible. Timings better than the Indian national record, have been achieved in Mumbai and Delhi.

One way out of this situation may be to dig deeper on the private participation front. Government authorities are justified in being disappointed that they do all the grassroot unearthing of talent (it is hard work). In their eyes, private players do the easier quarter of working with the best. That is by and large, a fair observation. But it also has to be admitted that the running ecosystem in India wouldn’t have grown this big had it not been for private participation. All those 2000 odd road races exist because there are private sponsors willing to support. One of the biggest Indian sponsors of road races -Tata via group company, TCS – is also possibly the biggest internationally with a clutch of prominent road races across a few continents supported by said company. However, as yet in India, there is no professional road running team supported by any company, that one has heard of. Should that happen, it is likely that a deeper exploration of training methods, training locales, identifying the best talent (irrespective of civilian and military distinction) and establishment of more training facilities (the sort oriented towards long distance running) would happen. Athletes have simple demands. One elite athlete wondered if there could be a training locale that was 6000 feet in elevation but was also a plateau with space for long training loops without too many ups and downs. An ideal training spot should have access to both tarmac and mud track. These are details that the private sector should be able to address. What one should however make sure is that money does not overplay its hand.

Illustration: Shyam G Menon

A concern in private participation in sports and creative pursuits is how the engagement between these human activities and the pressure to make monetary sense, plays out. For example, imagination by money and media typically favor short duration races and sports that deliver quick results. It is a quest to gratify the impatient human being. The world of ultramarathons knows this well. When it came to pitching for a ticket to the Olympics, they had to showcase their shortest distance and also make it trail in the hope that scenic backdrops would sustain broadcasters’ interests. That mission is still on. Or remember this more biting angle – heavy traffic and pollution, which are among the problems runners out on their daily jogs (and cyclists out on their daily rides) face, are partly a private sector gift. You can blame it on gullible customers but let’s not forget – manufacturers have gleefully crammed our environment with vehicles using this incentive and that. It is great sales but hardly great for quality of life, those daily runs included. It is why imagination by money matters but only to a point. It is why CSR, designed to improve how companies are perceived, can never convince as well as genuine change. Nothing like a change in our minds. Transposed to running it means – no matter whichever external constituency agrees to pitch in and assist, the desire to take the marathon in India to greater heights has to come from the collective of runners. The solution will have to be one that maintains interest in the sport in a sustained fashion but banks equally on empathy for it by government, support from the private sector and a culture that wants long distance running to continue and grow in Indian life. That last bit is where the average recreational runner becomes important. He / she forms the biggest component in the ecosystem; the passion which keeps running alive. Do we want marathoners from India to be world class? Will we set the best in our midst, up for greater success?

The late Shivnath Singh’s 2:12:00 may be a mere set of numbers on the clock. But trying to get past it and improve further, shows us so much about how we let ourselves down and as much about what we can do.

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai)        

PHOENIX

Meenal Kotak (photo: courtesy Meenal)

On June 23, when Indian ultrarunner Meenal Kotak set a new national mark of 680.2249 kilometres covered in the six day-race category of the Six Days in the Dome event in Milwaukee, USA, it was her best performance yet since an injury saw her stay off running for over eight months in 2019.

That year, Meenal was diagnosed with a painful case of slip disc in the L4 and L5 vertebrae and advised bed rest. There was no running. She remained indoors, life largely limited to her room and bed. It was a testing period. Besides the lack of physical activity, her mind went for a toss. Runners, especially ultrarunners, are known to pile on miles in training. The regular training helps them stay positive; in a high-endorphin, motivated zone. When such levels of physical activity get suddenly pulled off, the mind may progressively slip into depression. Meenal had cause for worry. Based on her prior performance in the ultramarathon, the Athletics Federation of India (AFI) had drafted her into the Indian team due to attend the 2019 24-hour world championship. That wouldn’t be possible now. Unable to run thanks to her slip disc problem, she grew acutely aware of the competition in the sport and the blunt truth that there is no shortage of new talent. No one is missed for long if they drop off the radar. Somebody else comes along and fills the vacancy. That is how it should be in the best interests of a team but when viewed from the individual runner’s perspective, it is precious chance missed. Meenal’s mind kept generating questions. Why am I injured? Why are things going well for others but not for me? When will AFI give me another chance? – she sank into a mental morass thinking so.

To compound matters, that known side effect of physical inactivity and mental depression manifested – she started to gain weight. “ My pacifier in this period was food. I ate. It was getting up, eating and taking medicines – that was my life,’’ she said. A major relief was the support she got from her husband, Sachin. True, the sight of others leaving for work and getting on with life was a downer. But the fact that she had somebody to talk to, meant she didn’t need to access any external assistance to tackle her depression. Then a leveller of sorts happened. By the first quarter of 2020, COVID-19 started to grow in India. Along with the pandemic, came lockdown. It dispatched everyone indoors, sporting activity came to a grinding halt worldwide and events were cancelled. Talking to this blog in early July, 2024, Meenal provided an honest overview of her bed-ridden predicament in times of pandemic. As lockdown took hold, suddenly, after months of finding herself inactive at home and left out from the active lifestyle-community, she felt a distinction crushed as people everywhere hunkered indoors. Everybody was in the same boat. Strangely, it was around this period when a whole world was hurting that Meenal began to heal.

Meenal Kotak; at the 2024 IAU 24H Asia-Oceania Championship in Australia (photo: courtesy Meenal)

Her residential complex in Gurgaon – where she had moved to from Vasant Kunj in neighbouring Delhi – hosted a long loop of close to two kilometres within its premises. Once she resumed walking indoors, she took the stairs down from her flat and walked longer distances on that loop. Sachin pitched in to help. With a view to encourage her on the comeback trail, he had taken to running during the time she was bed ridden and now with him for company, Meenal slowly worked her way up from running one kilometre to covering five kilometres. “ It took me a month to accomplish this,’’ she said. The loop within her residential complex was a genuine blessing to facilitate this progression. It meant she could run at night as well, something difficult for a woman to do in Delhi. For many people, five kilometres run in a day would seem enough. Not when you are a national level ultrarunner trying to return to where one was before slip disc felled the athlete. Meenal persevered. In all, she estimates, she would have taken 14-15 months to reach close to her old levels of mileage in training. And it wasn’t a simple reset; it was a reset with significant changes.

Prior to her injury, Meenal’s idea of training for the ultramarathon had focused mainly on accumulating high mileage. She used to run 600 to 650 kilometres every month and her weekend training included long runs of eight hours and 12 hours. It was just running and running. Post injury, on the comeback trail, that homogeneity transformed to a blend of strength training, stretching and training runs. Of these, strength training became the most important new ingredient as regards the body. She now works out with weights; her strength training session lasts one hour and is repeated thrice a week. Alongside, she settled for a slightly reduced mileage in her training runs. Her current monthly mileage is around 580 kilometres and her long runs range from six hours to eight hours. But the most significant tweak lay elsewhere; it was a tweak in her approach to races.

In April 2022 she registered for her first event in many months – a 12 hour-race in Bengaluru. She completed the race covering 90 plus kilometres in the stipulated time. What stayed in mind was the lightness of being she felt. “ When you enter an event after three years, the pressure is off. Unlike before when I was a known competitor tracked for my performance, thanks to the three year-gap, people seemed to have forgotten about me. It was good to have no pressure. That was a real upside. The downside was that my old friends in running had graduated to a different league and I didn’t know anyone around to say hello to,’’ Meenal said, adding, “ it was a good learning – change is the only constant in life. Records and achievements are meant to be broken.’’ Somewhere in that mix of altered scenario and the maturity of an older self, she realized that one better run for oneself rather than any glory. Even if there is some greater glory to chase, for the athlete, focus has to be on giving one’s best and forgiving oneself if things go wrong. It makes no sense to groom setbacks into dark moods that are difficult to climb out of. Roughly two years later, that realization would prove very useful in connection with her participation in events in Taiwan and Australia.

Meenal Kotak; from the event in Milwaukee, USA (photo: courtesy Meenal)

Meanwhile in 2022, in order to set a steady and systematic journey to her old endurance levels, she didn’t immediately vault from the 12 hour-race at Bengaluru to a 24-hour one. Instead, she did in all, three 12 hour-races that year to establish a solid foundation. In 2023 she participated in the Tuffman 24-hour race in Chandigarh and set a new personal best (PB) of 187 kilometres covered, an improvement over her earlier PB of 175 kilometres. Meenal is not a fast runner. Her forte is endurance; sustaining an effort for a longer period of time. And in this category, she had known for a while that her heart was in attempting multi-day events. It meant attempting runs of duration exceeding 48 hours, which was the maximum she had done till then. With this in mind, Meenal looked overseas for good opportunities and came across the event titled Six Days in the Dome in Milwaukee, USA. It had a 72-hour race, which although not well recognized as race-duration in the multi-day running fraternity was still a sensible bridge for her between the 48 hours she was familiar with and Milwaukee’s flagship six-day event, which she hoped to try at some point. She registered for the race. Sachin joined her as support crew (he does so for most of her races and Meenal finds the arrangement a big morale booster). The race turned out to be good for Meenal; in the stipulated 72 hours, she covered 379 kilometres. “ I really enjoyed those three days. It motivated me to explore deeper, the multi-day format,’’ Meenal said.

Likely taking note of her performance at Chandigarh and Milwaukee, the AFI included her in the Indian team for the 2023 IAU 24H World Championships and the 2024 IAU 24H Asia-Oceania Championships. Man proposes, God disposes. While training for the world championship (it was to take place in Taipei in December 2023), she sensed a niggle in her back. The old slip disc problem, although improved, hadn’t totally disappeared. She pulled out of the event in October. Under normal circumstances such withdrawal would demoralise any athlete. It may spark brooding and visitations to the dark zone in the head. But the post injury, new Meenal took it philosophically. She took the next 2-3 months, easy. From January 2024, she started her training for the six day-race in Milwaukee, scheduled for June. It was around this time that she got the call from AFI seeking her participation in the IAU 24H Asia-Oceania Championships. She had to accept the offer but there was a challenge. In her new cycle of training with Milwaukee in mind, until March 2024, Meenal hadn’t done a 12 hour-run, often considered vital to get ready for a 24 hour-race. She located two 12 hour-events – in Ahmedabad and Delhi – and participated in them to reacquaint herself with the experience and understand where she stood. “ I knew thereafter that I was good for 12 hours. But I couldn’t guarantee how things would be beyond that,’’ Meenal said. The Asia-Oceania championships in Australia didn’t play out well for Meenal. “ I was hoping to cover 185-190 kilometres. But I ended up with 168 kilometres. It wasn’t my day,’’ she said. Importantly, she didn’t let the reversal in fortunes, lead her into a pit of despair. She reverted her focus to the upcoming six day-race in Milwaukee.

Meenal Kotak; from the event in Milwaukee, USA (photo: courtesy Meenal)

June 2024; the race in Milwaukee featured several strong runners. “ I didn’t look at the entry list, which was displayed there. I didn’t want any pressure on myself,’’ Meenal said. The event in the US was set within an indoor stadium that held an ice-skating rink. It was therefore cold; a constant low temperature. Indoor stadium meant, there was no sunlight. On the other hand, precisely because of the synthetic setting, it was a controlled ambiance. The first day of the race went off well for Meenal. In line with her expectations, the second and third days proved to be tough. She neither ran nor slept properly. On the fourth day, things began to look up. On that day, the fifth and the sixth, she had her first taste of hallucination. There was a display board in the stadium featuring a woman’s image on it. Meenal felt the woman touch her on her shoulder, running with her and conversing with her. Some others around had more serious hallucinatory issues. “ One runner started hallucinating about a murder,’’ she said. Eventually, Meenal completed the race with a new national best for women. She thinks Indians have a talent for resilience. They can take a lot. It’s part of the South Asian package. Now 44 years old, Meenal’s wish is that somewhere on the way to her fifties or in her fifties, she should try the 52 day-Sri Chinmoy Self-Transcendence 3100 Mile Race.               

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai. For more on Meenal, please click on this link: https://shyamgopan.com/2017/12/21/after-the-race-the-journey/)         

THE 2:12:00 CONUNDRUM

Photo and imaging: Shyam G Menon

The longest standing national record in Indian athletics at present, the late Shivnath Singh’s 2:12:00 for the men’s marathon set in 1978, has become the target in mind for Indian elite marathoners.

The reason for the emergent urgency in addressing the national record is that unlike before, when qualifying standards for major international championships were short of the Indian national record, performance levels globally now are such that qualifying standards require to complete the marathon in timing that is faster than India’s national record. So, breaking the national record has become the only way forward for Indian elite marathoners. As one elite marathoner put it, “ there is no other option. The city marathons of Delhi and Mumbai will keep happening and the best among us at that given instance, will get a podium finish. But the national record has to be surpassed for the sport to move forward.’’

Most elite marathoners one speaks to admit to breaking the national record being a private and a larger, shared project but they say it such that it doesn’t weigh on their mind like a burden capable of dampening current performance. The goal has to sit lightly; a goal and yet not an obsessive, heavyweight one. Nobody sees breaking the national record as an impossible task because in today’s marathon environment with Kelvin Kiptum’s world record standing at 2:00:35 and timings by foreign elite runners at nodal Indian events itself being less than 2:10, a timing of 2:12:00 is nothing. As an athlete this blog spoke to put it (tad philosophically perhaps), India sits geographically in the middle with the centres of African running like Kenya, Uganda and Ethiopia to the west and Asia’s power house in running – Japan – to the east. So, it should be possible to improve. And yet, the wait has been long and there is evidently a puzzle to crack.

At least one coach of Indian elite athletes told this blog that a challenging aspect in the marathon was nutrition, especially dietary supplements. Elite athletes have to be very careful when it comes to their nutrition; they have to get the best nutrient intake for their sport without courting any prohibited substance. Such sports related food technology is considerably developed abroad. As example, the coach pointed to how Indian athletes in some disciplines other than the marathon elect to train overseas for long periods of time. This angle found empathy with some elite marathoners too. In fact, a common factor one finds when talking to Indian elite athletes, post-race at major events, is this trajectory of them performing well till 30-35 kilometres and struggling thereafter. “ I don’t know why. We do well for three fourths of a race and then lose out,’’ an elite runner said.

To an extent, this may be seen in the difference between the Indian national records in half marathon and the full, and their respective counterparts at the world level. The Indian national record in the half marathon is 1:00:30 (Avinash Sable in 2020) while the world record is 57 minutes and 31 seconds (Jacob Kiplimo of Uganda in 2021). Double the distance to 42.2 kilometres and the difference in timing between the national and world records is almost four times higher. Training in environments linked to a culture of endurance sports is another option. There is talk of at least a few elite marathoners potentially training in north Africa ahead of the next Olympics.

While all these are possible steps to improve, it still doesn’t answer why 2:12:00 has stayed so difficult to break. After all, as anyone would argue, the late Shivnath Singh had very few of the present-day technological advantages, sponsors and launch pads and even if the national record per se is taken off the equation, 2:12:00 is nowadays no big time in the larger marathon world. Among Indian athletes, the closest anyone has got to, to that mark, is Gopi Thonakal with his 2:13:39 at the 2019 Seoul Marathon. However, there are two other points that appear to hold relevance for India’s 2:12:00 journey, if one were to make it a pilgrimage.

First, although India has hundreds of marathons happening annually, an event that is a proper confluence of weather conditions, excellent course and race support is still hard to find. Where a flat, fast course is available, the weather may be tough; where the weather is good, the course still twists and turns or has gradients – so on. Indeed, for many observers of the sport, it is a puzzle why event organizers in India haven’t sculpted one perfect, fast course. Or, why no city appears to pride itself in having such a course to its credit with a race in the best part of the year. Or why not even a superb, flat, fast paced loop of modest mileage hasn’t been devised and maintained for a 42.2 kilometre-annual race that is a celebration of improved timing.

Second, elites are typically groomed from a pool of top-notch talent. By that logic, to breach 2:12:00 and improve further, there has to be first a big enough pool of people who run 2:20:00 and faster. It is by grooming this pool and competition within the pool that still better timings may be had. The argument even today is that such a pool, in India, is only growing. It is not big enough. Still, the coach this blog spoke to, said that he has the minimum number of elite runners required at hand, and was confident of producing results. Elite athletes were even more confident. Somebody just has to crack the record. Once that is done, they viewed getting past 2:12:00 like a longstanding collective mental block, flushed open. “ I am sure we have people who will do 2:07 and 2:08,’’ one of the elite athletes this blog spoke to, said.

There is one more reason – an unconfirmed but certainly speculated one – why breaking 2:12 has gathered a bit of urgency. Besides the fact that 2:12:00 is now slower than the qualifying mark for top international competitions, there is the fear that a sport which struggles for so long to break said barrier may wane in priority for national selectors piecing together teams for major competitions. Indian marathoners can’t risk having that happen to the marathon.  

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai)

FINDING LIFE

Nilanjan Guha Majumder (photo: Shyam G Menon)

It is not always that one finds a cycling story behind a simple recommendation on food.

I did and it was more than cycling that I found; it was the story of an interesting existence.

Early September 2023, a bid to contain one’s cost of living in Leh, saw freelance journalist search for Ladakhi food. I knew from past experience that it may prove futile for as has happened in many tourist-destinations, in Leh too, the culinary preference of outsiders overshadows what is locally consumed. One finds stylish cafes and restaurants catering to the taste buds of moneyed visitors who expect what they like everywhere they go and are willing to pay for it. It’s one of the call signs of new India; life resembles an airport – hunger is addressed not by eating affordable food but by demonstrating that one has the capacity to afford no matter what the cost.

Still, given my need had been whittled down to just the local bread or something similarly basic, I was hopeful of defiant culinary islands holding out against market forces. My search for Ladakhi food brought me to a kitchen at one end of Leh’s market and a conversation with the owners who highlighted the nutritional and economic sense in local food but admitted they too had succumbed to the new trend. “ It is affordable and it is nutritious,” the lady in the kitchen said before throwing her hands up to signal larger forces at play. There wasn’t a market big enough to support an eatery focused on Ladakhi food. On the bright side, the conversation was good. It’s the usual case, when two parties equally disappointed with contemporary drifts, meet. The kitchen had one customer. He sat there eating, quietly. At the end of my chat with the owner of the enterprise, the customer recommended that I try a kitchen elsewhere in town, which continued to offer local cuisine. That’s how I met Nilanjan. I was contemplating what to do, at the junction where Zangsti Road met Changspa Road and Sankar Road, when he emerged from the eatery. In season of Ladakh Marathon, his physicality hinted of cyclist. A short Q&A proved it right. A few days later, we conversed over lunch at a dhaba nearby.

An only child, Nilanjan Guha Majumder grew up in Uttarpara, Kolkata. His father worked with Customs & Central Excise; his mother was a housewife and entrepreneur. He did his schooling at Amarenda Vidyapith. He took to swimming when he was eight years old. Cycling was an early entrant to his life; it was his mode of transport in Uttarpara, famous for hosting Hindustan Motors, manufacturers of the Ambassador car, an icon of the India before economic liberalization. During his school days, Nilanjan loved playing cricket and featured in competitions up to the district level. College changed all that. Life became focused on academics (he still found time for volleyball and athletics). He graduated in computer studies from an institution in Bengaluru and then followed that up with a masters from Kolkata. Then, he joined Tech Mahindra in Pune. He also took a transfer back to Kolkata.

From Nilanjan’s rides in Ladakh / en route to Mahe, returning from Hanle (photo: Nilanjan Guha Majumder)

In 2007, he married his long-time girlfriend, who he knew from his schooldays. He shifted employment to Cognizant. Then, a while later, tragedy struck. Over five years spanning 2010 to 2015, both his parents and his grandmother, passed away. That was three people close to him, gone. “ I realized that nothing is permanent,’’ he said. In 2018-2019, Nilanjan and his wife decided to separate (the divorce came through in 2020). They remain good friends. In 2019, he shifted back to Bengaluru and acquired a new partner but the relationship broke up within a year.

Around the same time, he also resigned from Cognizant. It happened gradually, like something progressed towards. Prior to leaving the company, COVID-19 had struck humanity. The pandemic reauthored office operations and work styles worldwide. Just when office as surrogate home became fashionable, the virus dispatched everyone back home and made an office of it. For those not part of any herd, it must have been a time of engaging options around how to design one’s life. Nilanjan decided to travel and work remotely. He worked as a volunteer at a farm in Mysore. The farm house was beautiful and life there was calm and peaceful. The volunteering gave him time to think and make up his mind on what to do – among them, find the resolve to resign his job. The urge to quit had been building up over the preceding months. Volunteering helped him see things in perspective and find the courage to actually put in his papers. Now, educated, experienced and between jobs, he volunteered full time at the farm. He also taught children at the local village.

The owner of the farm was a dropout from the corporate world, who wished to start a school with a difference. Thanks to COVID, the situation was so bad that such plans had to be put on hold. Nilanjan had to move. He did so; to Guhagar on Maharashtra’s Konkan coast and another farm, where he volunteered. Amidst the new stint at volunteering, he also operated as a guide for tourists arrived to indulge in adventure sports. But a disagreement between the business partners concerned, saw the enterprise he worked at, shut down. Courtesy social media, he found another opportunity to volunteer in Himachal Pradesh. The location was near Banjar. According to Nilanjan, he was supposed to run a café in partnership with the owner of the facility; the larger enterprise was to be a travel company with focus on outings in the Tirthan Valley.  Around July 2022, he packed his bags and left Guhagar for Himachal Pradesh. Set to follow him, was a parcel.

From Nilanjan’s rides in Ladakh / camping in a meadow the day before crossing Wari La (photo: Nilanjan Guha Majumder)

Six years earlier, in 2016, Nilanjan had taken to cycling in a manner more committed than the commuting of his childhood. With a LA Sovereign MTB for steed, he had joined a cycling club in Kolkata. The Sovereign soon gave way to a Montra MTB. As his interest picked up and he met serious cyclists, he acquired a Java Velos 2 road bike. He took the Java with him, when he shifted to Bengaluru, a city known for its regular bicycle races and activities around cycling. During one of his rides in the city, he met Anand (Andy) and joined the latter’s cycling group. He also started going for trail runs at Avalahalli. After much use, the Java was sold to a person in Chennai. Nilanjan contacted Venkatesh Shivarama (Venky) of WheelSports in Bengaluru to buy a Polygon Bend R2, a gravel bike (it is capable of both tarmac and offroad and can be used for bikepacking trips). The new bicycle was delivered to Nilanjan in Pune. He rode it all the way to Guhagar. And when he shifted to Himachal Pradesh, the Polygon followed; it was parceled to him by Sunil Kumar Sahu, who Nilanjan trusts with transporting his bicycle. On the map, Nilanjan was now parked in Himachal Pradesh, south of Ladakh, a region loved by cyclists, climbers, hikers, runners – indeed anyone who likes freedom and exploration.

In some ways, the whole thing wasn’t accidental. Ladakh had been on Nilanjan’s mind from two to three years before his shift to Tirthan Valley. He had this vague idea of a plan – cycle from Himachal to Ladakh to Kashmir, Gujarat and South India before linking back to Kolkata. “ I had no idea what to expect. I am not a goal-oriented guy. I am a curious person, someone who keeps learning and possibly therefore, develops skills,’’ he said. Meanwhile, life in Tirthan wasn’t playing out as he would have wished it to. It seemed time to move again and explore. His former wife, who had stayed a good friend, pitched in to help. On July 28, 2022, Nilanjan set off for Ladakh on his Polygon. He proceeded to Manali and onward through the new Atal Tunnel to Sisu. There he met two friends from Kolkata and cycled with them to Sirchu. From thereon, he cycled alone. He rode via Tso Kar, Puga and Hanle to Leh, reaching there around August 20. After a brief halt, he cycled via Wari La to Nubra and returned to Leh via Khardung La. “ By now, I was in love with Ladakh,’’ he said.

The quest now was to figure out a means to hang on. Nilanjan likes photography. He approached a studio in Leh to see if the pictures he had taken, would sell. During the ensuing interaction with Rigzin and his uncle, Lobsang Visudha, Nilanjan came to know of the possibility of teaching computer applications to school children. He volunteered at Mahabodhi Residential School at Choglamsar in Leh. He taught computer studies for two and a half months. Over time, that volunteer work evolved into a proper job. From March 2023, he has been teaching there as a regular employee. Nilanjan is now a school teacher in Leh. According to him, his salary is considerably lower than what the IT industry used to pay him. But he has peace. In comparison, it was difficult to find peace in a corporate environment. During his days of volunteering at the school, he made friends with the local people. They helped him find an affordable place to stay in Leh.  “ This phase has given me a strong sense of purpose. I like guiding students,’’ he said adding that he now has a feeling of having found what he was looking for.

From Nilanjan’s rides in Ladakh / on the approach to Tso Kar (photo: Nilanjan Guha Majumder)

When I met him in September 2023, Nilanjan led an active lifestyle mixing regular workouts, running and cycling with his newfound role of school teacher. On weekends, he went for long bicycle rides (we met at the dhaba after he had finished a trip up and down, Khardung La). The Polygon has held up well, he said. He made one modification to the bicycle – he replaced the rear chainrings, originally of a 11-32 configuration, with a 11-34. It helped him get a better gear ratio for climbs. Else, the bike is pretty much unaltered. Being a gravel bike designed to do bikepacking trips as well, its gearing doesn’t have the wide range of the classic tourer’s. But Nilanjan says, he hasn’t had reason to complain despite life in Ladakh. On long trips, he rides with loaded panier bags. So far, the bicycle has tackled all the uphill, downhill and flat terrain thrown at it.

A couple of days after this chat, a friend and I had Ladakhi food at the kitchen Nilanjan recommended. It was good. But above all, finding Ladakhi food amidst the predictable trends of the market, was a pleasure.

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai)    

DISAPPOINTED WITH LEVEL OF CORPORATE SUPPORT FOR INDIAN JUNIOR ATHLETICS: AFI PRESIDENT

Adille Sumariwalla (photo: Shyam G Menon)

The level of interest shown by India’s corporate sector in the country’s athlete nurturing program for track and field events at the junior level, has been disappointing, Adille Sumariwalla, president, Athletics Federation of India (AFI), said.

“ Everybody wants a Neeraj Chopra. Nobody wants to put money into the grassroot building of athletes,’’ he told this blog on November 4, eve of the 2023 IAU 50KM World Championships, held recently in Hyderabad. Chopra won gold in javelin throw at the 2020 Tokyo Olympics (held in July-August, 2021) to become the second Indian after Abhinav Bindra to earn an individual gold medal at the Olympics. Bindra had won gold in the men’s 10 metre air rifle, at the 2008 Olympics. While gold medal-winning elite athletes are sought after by companies wishing to feature them in their marketing campaigns, efforts to spot, nurture and grow talent at the grassroot junior level – basically, the foundation on which the story of elite achievements rests – has eluded the support of corporates.

Sumariwalla pointed out that so far, the junior programme for scouting and grooming potential in track and field events has been funded by the AFI itself. It is among the largest such programs in the world and many senior level performers owe their discovery and subsequent passage to limelight, to the program. Yet, companies have overlooked the sustained engagement that is required to support this program. They prefer instead, the ease of returns found in marketing campaigns featuring elite athletes. This is when, according to Sumariwalla, a mere spoonful of the total Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) outlay of the top 20 Indian corporates exceeds the government’s annual sports budget. “Companies want to use corporate social responsibility money for advertising. They want to know how many eyeballs they will fetch by sponsoring the athletes. Therefore, they have no interest in supporting grassroot level athlete development programs. They are not interested in sustained engagement,” he said.

AFI has been organising the National Inter District Junior Athletics Meet (NIDJAM) since 2003. “ The way it goes is that first, 600 districts organise the district championships in two age groups – under 14 and under 16 years. The smallest districts have about 300-350 participants. The bigger districts have anything between 3,500 and 4,500 participants. The district championships are first held. Then they select 13 athletes to come for the National Inter District Junior Athletics Meet (NIDJAM). Last time, 599 districts took part. We had 6,500 children who were selected from roughly 10 lakh children who take part,” Sumariwalla said, outlining the scale of the program.

Among the state governments, Bihar government had offered limited funds. Recently, REC Ltd, a state-owned company, came aboard, offering funds for NIDJAM. But these are exceptions. “ In these 17 years, hardly any corporate evinced interest in funding or partially supporting NIDJAM. A couple of companies helped in a brief manner. AFI has supported the program internally for the last 17 years. Children get their train fare, free accommodation and free food. They come with their parents. We also feed the parents. At times we are feeding about 10,000 people each day,” Sumariwalla said. Last year, the Bihar government took up a portion of that expenditure, mainly food and accommodation. REC Ltd took up the train fare expenses partly.

AFI has sought corporate support for the program. Unfortunately, as the federation discovered, corporate interest in sports is more around marketing campaigns featuring successful elite athletes and less in sustained, long term engagement. “ We have been reaching out to corporates. The constant question from companies is: can we get Neeraj or for how many days can we get Neeraj? My answer has always been: no, you can’t get Neeraj,” he said, reiterating that sponsors need to support sports at the grassroot level. Without grassroot level programs, the pipeline feeding talent to senior athletics gets weakened.

There is also an emergent need to reimagine and support the junior program. At the last NIDJAM, 599 districts took part and 6,500 children were selected from among 10 lakh who took part in the district championships. AFI’s focus for these young athletes is to allow them to explore at least three different sports. “ We want them to have an overall development. We don’t want them to start specialisation at the age of 13, 14 and 15 and probably till the age of 17. We found that those who specialise early burn out fast. Those who took up completely different sports have done well,’’ he said.

What worries is that the conversion ratio from junior to senior athletics is very low at three to five percent. “ If we are going to lose all our athletes by the time, they are 18 years old, the program is of no use. Therefore, we do not want them to specialise in events too early on. We are even thinking of changing the national structure of the events to make sure that they participate in all kinds of odd events,” he said. The above illustrates the challenges the junior program faces and also the need to support it in a sustained fashion such that the rates of successful transition to senior athletics don’t hover at discouraging levels. AFI’s talent nurturing program at the junior level is among the best in the world. “ Supporting it is the most important thing for the development of athletics. Some of our top-notch athletes have come out of this program,” Sumariwalla said.

Notwithstanding his disappointment at corporates’ obsession with successful senior athletes, Sumariwalla believes that senior athletes’ performance has a salutary effect on the performance of junior athletes and the interest in them. For instance, the lustre around a Neeraj Chopra brushes off positively on a whole world of athletics in India. Brands such as Adidas, Puma and Asics have shown interest in AFI. “ We have been able to convince HSBC to look at the women’s program. We now have its support for the women’s program. Reliance has come in but not as large as it should be. If we do a valuation of AFI we are not even getting 10 percent of that by way of support,” he said.

With reference to the ultramarathon (Sumariwalla was in Hyderabad in connection with the 2023 IAU 50KM World Championships), he said that AFI will try to secure official recognition for the sport. Such recognition helps events and athletes to be supported by government (airfare, daily allowance etc may be possible). The classical route to recognition was the admission of a given sport to the Olympics. Ultrarunning is yet to be a part of the Olympic Games. However, at present, the Indian government also recognizes and supports sports that are not part of the Olympics. For example, squash wasn’t part of the Olympics for a long time but it was recognized by the government (recent news reports said, squash will be there in the 2028 Los Angeles Olympic Games). The way to obtain such recognition is via better performance by athletes. Once athletes return great performances and the same grabs public attention, support and traction, the government will feel motivated to recognize and back ultrarunning. Podium finishes are thus critical. The 2023 IAU 50KM World Championships witnessed a silver medal for India in the men’s team category. Further in the past, India has won podium positions in the team category at the continental championships.

According to Sumariwalla, ultrarunning is an extension of athletics and the government needs to support it. “ I think it will happen. It’s just a matter of time,’’ he said.

(The authors, Latha Venkatraman and Shyam G Menon, are independent journalists based in Mumbai)

ANATOMY OF A FINISH

Amit Gulia (photo: Shyam G Menon)

On the morning of September 8, 2023, much before the winner of the year’s Silk Route Ultra (SRU) crossed the finish line, another runner had completed the race. He would settle for fourth place as he belonged to the first batch of runners that set off the previous evening to tackle the 122-kilometre distance from Kyagar to Leh, up and over the 17,618 feet high-Khardung La. Judged by net timing, the Ladakhi runners of the second batch were faster. They would sweep the podium; first, second and third. Still, Amit Gulia’s timing was no small achievement. The 16 hours, 21 minutes and 25 seconds he took to place fourth was the first sub-17-hour finish in the race by a non-Ladakhi. In the ecosystem of the Ladakh Marathon, an event with altitude as its biggest challenge, non-Ladakhi runners are the outsiders taking the brunt of elevation.

Amit’s journey to that September finish had commenced five years earlier. Based in Chandigarh, Amit, 40, has a background in medical research He is a medical writer and since the past one year, he is also chief coach at Skechers Go Run club in Chandigarh. A runner since the age of 32-33, he has never run a marathon officially. He did so in training and the one thing he liked to do as runner, was to run long distances. That was how his drift to the ultramarathon happened. He found himself completing a marathon in training with others and still having room for more mileage. His first ultra was the popular event at Bhatti Lakes; a pucca start to his innings.

Thanks to their long distances, ultramarathons demand preparation, strategy and support. When Amit attempts races requiring support crew, that role is typically taken up by two people close to him. There is his wife Gurjeet Kaur, who like Amit, is a runner and a medical researcher. She takes much interest in his running. Then there is Vijay Pande, an engineer and runner based in Bengaluru, who Amit often consults to devise approach and strategy for the projects he undertakes. The two had met at a past edition of the Mashobra Ultra, which was among Amit’s first official forays into distances exceeding the length of a marathon. It was Vijay who introduced Amit to training with the altitude mask.

A December 2022 article by Ashley Mateo in Runner’s World explains what the altitude / elevation mask does. How it works is very different from training at altitude. When one trains at altitude, there is increased production of a hormone called erythropoietin (or EPO). It triggers the body to produce more red blood cells and form new blood vessels. This enables the body to deliver more oxygen to the muscles which in turn means faster and more efficient running, particularly when one returns to sea level. Altitude masks have valves or vents that regulate air intake. They can alter the quantity of air getting in but they don’t affect the mix of gases in the air inhaled. Consequently, when used while training at low altitude, one does not get the same benefits as when training at elevation. It is not an exactly similar situation. However, restricting the air intake contributes to something called inspiratory muscle training. It increases the strength of the respiratory muscles which can eventually translate to the ability to bring more air into one’s lungs. That’s potentially more oxygen that can get into the bloodstream. More oxygen in the muscles means one finding it easier to exercise. In other words, the mask-route is not precisely the same as training at altitude but it has an oblique benefit by way of strengthening the respiratory muscles.

The route of Silk Route Ultra with elevation of starting line, finish and key points in between (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Amit’s use of the device started during his preparations for the 2017 edition of La Ultra The High, an event with a basket of ultramarathons happening in Ladakh. Initially, the mask was difficult to use. But given the event he had signed up for, Amit had no other option; he persevered. That year, he won the 222 km-category of La Ultra The High, the first Indian to do so (archived results of the event show the winner’s timing as 38 hours, 20 minutes). It was Amit’s first ultramarathon at altitude; the route of the 222 km-race touched both Khardung La and Wari La (over 17,400 feet high). The template for acclimatization he fashioned for that race, has remained thereafter his rule book for races in Ladakh. Besides regular training at low altitude and the use of the altitude mask for some of the sessions therein, the other noteworthy aspect was Amit’s protocol for pre-race days in Leh. Unlike the typically anxious participants of these races who continue running at elevation or make last minute dashes to high altitude in a bid to get familiar with the environment, Amit focused on rest. In the fortnight he reserved for acclimatization before the 2017 La Ultra The High, he rested in Leh and walked around locally. There weren’t any runs, car or bike trips to still higher altitude as preparation for the race and its high passes. What is generally overlooked in such cases is that for people coming to high altitude from the outside, post-exercise recovery and healing in activities done during the acclimatization period, misses the richer oxygen levels of lower elevation. “ In my opinion, visits to high altitude and exerting oneself during the acclimatization phase before a race, inflicts damage without adequate time for healing and recovery. I stayed off such practices. Consequently in 2017, when the race started, I was feeling as though I was running in the plains. I have been repeating this protocol ever since. I prepare in the plains and rest ahead of a race at altitude,’’ Amit said.

Following the first-place finish at the 2017 La Ultra The High, in 2019, he was the top finisher among non-Ladakhi runners in the 72 kilometre-Khardung La Challenge (KC). He covered the distance in 9:22:50 to place eleventh among men. The next two years were claimed by COVID-19. Sports events came to a halt worldwide or were reduced to a trickle. In 2022, when the Ladakh Marathon returned after the pandemic, Amit and his friend Rakesh Kashyap, decided to attempt the inaugural edition of SRU. They planned to do it like a training run ahead of attempting the year’s Spartathlon in Greece. Joining them were Munish Jauhar and Anmol Chandan, also from Chandigarh, who had signed up to attempt the SRU and KC respectively. Amit followed the same acclimatization pattern as he did for the 2017 La Ultra The High. The race started well for him. At the 60 kilometre-mark, he was comfortably positioned in the pecking order, when he began having problems consuming the energy gels he had brought along. In the biting cold of altitude, the gels had become thick in consistency and when consumed, got stuck in his throat. He wanted hot water to wash it down. But at the aid stations, he passed, hot water was not available. He was told that he may get it further up on the way to Khardung La, at the aid station in North Pullu. But Amit sensed it was becoming a choice between pushing his luck and preserving his well-being for Spartathlon. He opted for the latter; he withdrew from the race. As did Rakesh, sometime later. Munish and Anmol had fine outings. Munish finished SRU in 19:47:40 to place seventh among 19 men in the fray; Anmol completed KC in 9:34:51 to place seventeenth among the 140 men in his category (source: 2022 Ladakh Marathon / SRU and KC results). Back in Leh and his throat condition addressed, Amit ran the event’s full marathon. In the weeks that followed, both he and Rakesh flew to Greece and completed Spartathlon.

Early morning September 8. Amit Gulia at the very front of the 2023 Silk Route Ultra; location: between North Pullu and Khardung La, not far from the pass (photo: Shyam G Menon)

By now Amit was sure that he would return to Ladakh for SRU. For the 2023 edition of SRU, he commenced training in mid-June. Besides his training runs, he worked out using the altitude mask. At the gym he frequented, he kept the treadmill at a good incline and walked with the altitude mask on. Each session with the mask lasted between 40 minutes to an hour. He did this twice a week. Once again Rakesh and Anmol joined him on the trip to Leh; this time all three would be running SRU. As the event drew close, Amit was sure that he was going to complete it within the stipulated cut-off time of 22 hours. Within that expectation, he set himself three options. The first was aggressive – cover the 122 kilometres in 15 hours to 15 hours and 15 minutes. Second, keep it sub-16 hours. In case both of the above proved tough, then do a sub-17. Third – complete the race at any cost. “ I have a habit of challenging myself,’’ Amit said over coffee at a café in Leh on September 11. Besides his goals in terms of overall timing for 2023 SRU, he divided the race into sections – Kyagar to Khardung, Khardung to North Pullu, North Pullu to Khardung La, Khardung La to South Pullu and South Pullu to Leh – to evolve a strategy and assign expectations. He planned to cover the first 50 kilometres in five hours and was happy when on race day, the stretch was actually done in five hours, 20 minutes. From Khardung to North Pullu, he had estimated a duration of three hours. It too was managed in and around the planned time. By now he had 50 per cent of the race in the bag and was the race leader. But the section from North Pullu to Khardung La proved tough.

The group of runners Amit was in – the first batch of the race – had left Kyagar, late evening on September 7. Aside from the odd street light at settlements like Khalsar and Khardung, the road wound on and uphill in utter darkness. By the time Amit commenced tackling the uphill from Khardung village to Khardung La, it was past midnight. The North Pullu-Khardung La portion came some hours after that. Sizable gaps separated the runners. Some proceeded alone; some stuck together. With traffic suspended for the duration of the race, it was quiet. One heard the sound of athletes breathing, the swishing of wind cheater fabric and the sound of shoes on gravel, as person passed by. An occasional nuisance were dogs, some of them, territorial. Race officials, moving up and down the road, chased the animals away. Viewed from far, sole stamp of runner’s presence in that vast, dark mountainous landscape was, each person’s headlamp. In between, one saw the brighter solar lamps of aid stations. Amit was ahead of everyone else, all by himself. “ I was feeling exhausted. I was shivering like hell. I had on, two pairs of gloves, three jackets and two caps. I was finding it difficult to drink water from the bottle,’’ he said. Amit reached the 17,618 ft-pass almost an hour later than what he had planned. The pass is a tricky place. Given the stretch spanning North Pullu to Khardung La as the place where many people withdraw due to exhaustion, reaching the pass in SRU, represents a milestone achieved. But with that can come a loss of appreciation for where exactly one is. The pass is high in elevation and bitterly cold. There is an aid station at Khardung La, where one can hydrate, get some nourishment and also rendezvous with drop-bags positioned in advance. Runners like Amit treat Khardung La carefully; they don’t let the milestone bit get into their head. Hanging around unnecessarily at the highest part of the race does nothing useful to the body. The emphasis is on shedding elevation. With the environment quite cold, oxygen level at the pass known to be lower than at sea level and his body feeling fatigued, Amit picked up a glass of hot soup from the aid station at the pass and quickly moved on. Ahead lay the long descent to Leh.

Amit does strength training thrice a week. He had trained for long descents. He was prepared for the downhill that follows Khardung La. But even he miscalculated what his needs may be, that September 8 dawn. It was a miscalculation on the logistics front. Layering and de-layering is how athletes functioning at altitude manage their attire to stay efficient. It is an act that seeks to strike a balance between protection from the elements, the temperature of one’s surroundings and the warmth, the body naturally generates as it works. Amit forgot to keep a drop-bag in advance at Khardung La so that he could de-layer in anticipation of the descent and the need of such faster movement to have less layers getting in the way. Minus drop-bag to leave his layers in, he stayed imprisoned in piles of clothing and gear that had served its purpose. So even as he exited Khardung La without wasting much time, he was bulky and hauling weight. He had on his upper layers, two layers on his legs, two pairs of gloves, two caps, hydration pack and trekking poles. Simply put, he couldn’t take advantage of the descent and run. He had kept his next drop-bag at South Pullu, several kilometres away on the Leh side. When on tired legs, every ounce of weight is acutely felt. Try running with too many layers on and one’s cocoon of clothing risks becoming unbearably warm. Till South Pullu, he moved inefficiently.

Amit Gulia on the final stretch from South Pullu to Leh (photo: courtesy Amit)

Meanwhile behind him, on the northern slopes of Khardung La, Amit’s friends were coping with a vastly different experience. Neither Rakesh nor Anmol own altitude masks. They had trained for SRU without it. According to Anmol, he compensated for the absence of such a gadget by resorting to high repetition interval training in the plains, which has the effect of improving respiratory efficiency. All that seems to have gone well. In retrospect, what happened after their training in Chandigarh was hugely different for the trio. In the pre-race acclimatization phase in Leh (11,500 ft), Anmol’s path and that of Rakesh, diverged sharply from Amit’s. Rest is very important in acclimatization. “ Amit does not do anything before a race at altitude. He rests. I reached Leh on August 28 and from then till around September 5, I piled on 70 to 80 kilometres in training. I don’t know why; that’s my style and it had worked for me in 2022,’’ Anmol said adding, “ Rakesh also put on similar mileage.’’ This time, the approach didn’t work. When this writer met Amit, Anmol and Rakesh in Kyagar, they appeared relaxed and in good spirits. But according to Anmol, at the start line of SRU late evening September 7, he was on tired legs. He realized he hadn’t recovered from all that running around in Leh.

The night of September 7, for about 30-35 kilometres since race commencement, Anmol and Amit were together. Then Amit pushed ahead. Around 60 kilometres covered and on the long ascent to Khardung La, Anmol began experiencing dizziness. He tuned into the sensation and decided to get it checked. Near North Pullu, he consulted the medical team that was present there with ambulance alongside. His oxygen saturation had dropped. He was otherwise feeling alert. It was very cold and so he was asked to try walking some more to see if the oxygen saturation level improved. Anmol figured that may not be viable. Such a walk would only be uphill given Khardung La was still some distance away. The terrain and direction of travel wouldn’t allow an improvement in his oxygen saturation unless he stopped or lost elevation. “ I told myself this is not a Kumbh Mela, something that happens only once in several years and therefore having to be done right now at any cost. I can always come back to try SRU again. I decided to quit the race there,’’ Anmol said.

Rakesh too gave up. But in his case, he may have misjudged his predicament. Rakesh’s exit from SRU was reportedly after some more distance (than Anmol) covered and it manifested as a collapse. Around the time of this incident, there was a bus carrying the baggage of KC runners (at 3AM that day, KC had commenced from Khardung village) and some runners who had retired from SRU, coming from North Pullu. Two of the runners in the bus helped this writer, recreate the scene. It was the morning of September 8. There were both KC and SRU participants running and walking on the road. The bus had just passed an ambulance parked by the roadside, when some distance away, one of the (above mentioned two) runners witnessed Rakesh collapse to his right side. Another runner, who was still in the race, stopped to tend to him. Upon reaching the scene, the bus driver halted the vehicle and honked to alert the ambulance behind. The runners from the bus stepped out to help. They told the racer who had stopped to assist Rakesh, to carry on as they were available. By then, the ambulance had arrived. Four people were required to help Rakesh into the ambulance. He kept saying that he was capable of continuing. But the doctor in the ambulance pointed to Rakesh’s collapse, put his foot down and said the race was over for him. “ It was between North Pullu and Khardung La, I would think 70 kilometres or so overall, from the start line of SRU,’’ one of the runners said. Rakesh received medical attention. He recovered. “ He is fine now,’’ Anmol told this blog on September 29. While on the SRU course, Amit knew nothing of what happened to his friends. He got updates only after he finished the race.

Amit Gulia crossing the finish line of the 2023 Silk Route Ultra in Leh (photo: courtesy Amit)

At South Pullu, Amit took 20-25 minutes to de-layer and have a warm cup of tea. Thus revitalized, he did a decent jog from there to Leh. “ I even pushed myself a bit,’’ he said, adding with a smile of satisfaction, “ if I remove all the time I lost to resting, and just aggregate the time spent moving, I clocked around 15 hours, 20 minutes and 10 seconds.’’ In all, over the 122 kilometres covered, Amit took three major breaks – at Khardung village, North Pullu and South Pullu. End to end, including any rest he may have availed, Shabbir Hussain of the Indian Army’s Ladakh Scouts regiment (he started the race one and a half hours after Amit did, in the second batch), won the 2023 SRU in 15:27:53. Amit would like to come back to Ladakh and improve his timing at SRU. “ There are some races, which are close to my heart. SRU is one of them. The finish line, located in Leh’s main market, is a fantastic experience. When I crossed the finish line, besides the spectators, there were people coming out from nearby shops to congratulate me. The congratulations in town continued the next day too,’’ he said.

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai. While the running community knows Amit as Amit Gulia, his official name – and the way it appears on race results – is Amit Kumar. At La Ultra The High, his name appears as Amit Chaudhary.)                  

“ I WOULD LIKE TO ATTEMPT 100 KM-RACES AND 24-HOUR STADIUM RUNS”

Shabbir Hussain (photo: Shyam G Menon)

An ultramarathon at altitude, is a bit like a mountaineering expedition.

As the race approaches, each participant withdraws into a cocoon, unique to one’s wiring. By September 6, 2023, the day of departure from Leh to Kyagar in Nubra Valley, it was clear that an element of imminent rendezvous with reality was beginning to wash over those set to attempt the 122-kilometer-long Silk Route Ultra (SRU). In Kyagar, some rested in their hotel rooms and stayed unseen. Some walked around, conversed and chatted, ostensibly to ease the gravity of the countdown. Among the less visible was Shabbir Hussain. He must be resting. Tomorrow is his, isn’t it? – although not verbatim, that was the tenor in response from his colleagues in the military and paramilitary; at least three of them – Stanzen Phuntsog, Tsewang Kundan (from Ladakh Scouts) and Phunchok Tashi (from the Indo-Tibetan Border Police [ITBP]) – stayed in circulation, playing the occasional game of table tennis to keep themselves occupied and distracted. The day before an important race and the hours leading to it, can be testing. Staying relaxed is easier said than done. Shabbir appeared only on and off. Would the ones to watch out for tomorrow be the ones seen the least today? – I wondered.

Several hours earlier, at the NDS Stadium in Leh, a small fleet of buses had manifested to transport the runners. I had chosen my bus for Kyagar at random and discovered a self-effacing runner conscious of his importance and yet wishing to be away from the glare it fetched, take his place in the seat in front. His credentials in running were clear from his physical appearance. Here comes the winner. Take us also up the pass along with you, Shabbir – that, yet again not verbatim, was however the substance of the greeting he received from the other runners in the bus. From different parts of India, some of them attempting the race again after being unable to complete in 2022, they all knew Shabbir as the man to watch out for. With Kundan, Stanzen and Tashi too in the same bus, our vehicle felt special. Turbo-charged?

Shabbir Hussain’s significance to the two ultramarathons – Khardung La Challenge (KC / 72 km) and SRU – that are part of the family of races constituting the Ladakh Marathon, may be understood from the event’s archived results. Both these races come up and over the 17,618 feet-high Khardung La, among the world’s highest motorable passes. It is an altitude with less oxygen; running becomes quite difficult. Additionally, the SRU has a start that is 50 kilometers farther away from the start line of KC. In other words, a SRU participant is more than a marathon old in terrain gaining elevation towards Khardung La by the time he reaches the village of Khardung, start point of KC. The 72 kilometer-KC made its debut in 2012. Shabbir started running KC in 2014. As per results available on Wikipedia (at the time of writing, the KC results of 2012, 2013 and 2014 didn’t feature on the Ladakh Marathon website), he finished first in six hours and 35 minutes. In 2015, Shabbir finished fourth with timing of seven hours, 16 minutes and 13 seconds. The winner in 2015 was Tsewang Tokdan (6:33:41). By 2016, Shabbir was back on the podium at KC, he placed second (6:53:35.04); the results indicate a photo-finish with Tokdan (6:53:35.04). The next year was clearly Shabbir’s; he finished first (6:23:50.26) in KC. He stayed first (6:50:38) at KC, in 2018. In 2019, he made it a hat-trick of triumphs, securing the top position with timing of 6:53:34. In 2022, he shifted to competing in SRU. He finished second (14:57:57) in the race. 

View of Darket (photo: courtesy Shabbir Hussain)

Shabbir was born and raised in Darket, a village roughly 20 kilometers away from Kargil towards the Leh side. Kargil is about 2700 feet lower in elevation compared to Leh (11,500 feet); it has an altitude of around 8780 feet (source: Wikipedia). He has three brothers and two sisters. Shabbir’s father worked as a laborer. The boy studied till tenth standard. As is widespread practice in Ladakh, he later joined the Ladakh Scouts regiment of the Indian Army. According to Shabbir, during his days in school, there wasn’t any indulgence in sports worth mentioning. However, soon after his acceptance into the Scouts, his ability to run was recognized. That was how he started landing up at the races of the Ladakh Marathon.

The event commenced in Leh, in 2012. That year, the men’s marathon (42 km) was won by Tsering Gyatso (3:36:18). In 2013, archived results show the men’s marathon sporting a new winner – Shabbir Hussain (3:25:33). “ I just ran the marathon and ended up first,’’ he said. In 2014, he shifted from the marathon to KC. Outside of Ladakh, Shabbir’s participation at races has been very limited and he has enjoyed no podium position. He travelled a couple of times with the team of Ladakhi runners Rimo Expeditions sent to the marathons of the plains. Away from the Ladakh Marathon, he also participated once in the 111 kilometer-race of La Ultra The High (also held in Ladakh) and secured a third place. “ When we train, we don’t think of podium position. We think of improving our timing. If you lost a position but gained in timing – it is fine. Similarly, a good position without good timing does not enthrall,’’ he said.

At Kyagar, Shabbir explained why he progressively drifted away from the marathon and stuck to KC and SRU. “ My forte is stamina. I find speed tough to generate,’’ he said. That was a day before the 2023 SRU set off late evening September 7 and Shabbir, running in the second batch of runners (the Ladakhi elites started one and a half hours after the rest of the field), showed that even in the ultramarathon, his pace – and that of the other runners from Ladakh Scouts – can be hard to match. They headed off into the night at a steady pace. Villagers who had lined up at road junctions to cheer the first batch, stayed back to encourage the local heroes. Shabbir felt that Ladakhi athletes like Jigmet Dolma and Nawang Tsering, who have embraced the marathon, have actually taken the tougher challenge of chasing speed. In comparison, he chose the path of less resistance – pursuing stamina. And yet that doesn’t totally sum up Shabbir for he digs a good challenge. In both the shift from the marathon to KC and the subsequent shift from KC to SRU, the main motivation he conceded, was “ challenge.’’  It’s probably why after winning the 2023 SRU, it isn’t a return to the same race that is playing on his mind. He wonders whether he should try the shorter KC next time, for in 2023, the KC winner, Rigzin Gyurmeth (6:31:41) of the army’s special forces, had come close to Shabbir’s timing from 2017 – 6:23:50.26. “ I would like to keep the course record,’’ Shabbir, 29, said smiling. He will take a decision on KC or SRU for 2024, closer to the event.

Shabbir Hussain finishing first in the 2023 Silk Route Ultra (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Morning of September 8. Fifteen hours, 27 minutes and 53 seconds after he set off from Kyagar, Shabbir crossed the finish line of SRU in Leh to win the 2023 edition of the race. Easily among the most iconic runners emerging from Ladakh Marathon, Shabbir would like to compete in ultramarathons outside Ladakh. Although news of races elsewhere now reaches Ladakh’s runners, Shabbir has to date not participated in an ultramarathon outside the union territory. “ I would like to attempt 100 km-races and 24-hour stadium runs,’’ he said. Top notch competitions in these disciplines, held under the auspices of the International Association of Ultrarunners (IAU), now happen in India. There are Indian teams participating. Many civilian runners also regularly take part in high profile road and trail-based ultramarathons overseas. A serving soldier, Shabbir’s future in the sport depends much on seniors empowered to take decisions. Hope they are listening.

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai.)

LINGSHET, LAMDON, LADAKH MARATHON – NAWANG’S STORY

Nawang Tsering (photo: Shyam G Menon)

The data in the phone-camera gives the time of the photograph as 8.42AM.

That was when on September 10, a wiry runner blew past the finish line of the 2023 Ladakh Marathon and won the race. A few steps past the finish, he lay down exhausted. Helped up by volunteers, he then picked his way to Leh’s NDS Stadium nearby, where the awards presentation was due.

A couple of days later, when this writer met him at a café in Leh, he still seemed a light, breezy presence on the planet. Soft spoken, mostly answering to the point and if a wind blew – likely to float off. Meet Nawang Tsering or as at 8.42AM on September 10 – two hours, 42 minutes and two seconds. And for this spectator from Mumbai, such timing at 11,500 feet elevation, where many of us find it difficult to jog!

Still when Nawang won the 2023 Ladakh Marathon, it wasn’t his best timing so far. He was marginally short of his own course record in Leh; 2:41:42, set in 2022. His personal best was 2:39:39, set at the 2022 New Delhi Marathon. At that time, it (2:39:39) appeared the best timing yet by a Ladakhi marathon runner (source: Administration of Union Territory of Ladakh, press statement dated March 29, 2022). However, it’s a long way off from the timings reported by top Indian marathon runners (for comparison: Shivnath Singh’s longstanding national record is 2:12:00 and Gopi T of the Indian Army who has since been the closest to that mark, clocked a personal best of 2:13:39 at the 2019 Seoul Marathon [source: World Athletics]). On the bright side, Nawang is 24 years old and only getting started. Besides, just as runners from the plains may be stretched doing a sub-three hour-marathon at altitude in Ladakh’s dry weather, a Ladakhi runner like Nawang, takes time to adjust to the heat and humidity of lower altitudes. All of which points to engaging discoveries and twists and turns ahead, in India’s marathon story.

Nawang hails from Lingshet, a village in the Sham region of Ladakh. It is a long way from Leh, to the south west. Although technically a part of Leh district, enquiries in Leh revealed that culturally, Lingshet used to be closer to Zanskar. For long, Lingshet was a remote place. There wasn’t a road leading right up to the village. Nawang’s father worked as a labourer. His mother died when he was in the third standard. He has two brothers and a sister. Nawang studied at Leh’s Lamdon Model Senior Secondary School. Even after he competed his twelfth standard some years ago, the school continues to be second home. He stays in the school hostel.

In his early childhood, Nawang recalled, it took three days to reach home from Leh. And in winter, passage to Lingshet entailed trekking on the frozen Zanskar River. Known as the Chadar Trek, it was until recently a much-coveted objective in adventure tourism with people paying a lot of money to experience walking on the frozen river in sub-zero temperatures. Global warming and consequent unreliability around the strength of the ice cover and problems associated with too many people arriving for the bragging rights of having walked the frozen river, have since taken the sheen off the trek. For Nawang though, the Chadar Trek was a winter reality. It was the only way he could go home during vacations (in Ladakh, the winter school break is longer than the summer one). As he grew up, the visits home appear to have dwindled. During the ninth and tenth standards, tuitions kept him in Leh. In the following years, it was running. Lingshet is now connected by road. But the boy, since become a man and devoted to a life in running, rarely goes home. Leh and Lamdon have become his address.

For much of his years in school, Nawang wasn’t into running. The bug bit in the eleventh standard. His inspiration was his friends – Tsering Stobgais and Jigmet Norbu – who had been to Mumbai (home of India’s biggest city marathon) and on their return begun to train. There was even a running club operated by his friends; they called it Cosmos. According to Stobgais, Cosmos was one among clubs of that sort, formed by the inmates of the school hostel to have informal tournaments. “ Back then, Leh did not have many sports tournaments. We had to devise our own,” Stobgais said, adding efforts are now afoot by former Cosmos members to recast the club into a body that spans both competitions at school and outside. At the time Nawang first saw his friends train, he didn’t have running shoes. His friends had visited Mumbai as part of the running team sponsored by Rimo Expeditions. The company provided team members new pairs of shoes. When his friends’ shoes became old, Nawang got to borrow a pair for his training runs. Then in 2014 or so, when the year’s edition of the Ladakh Marathon was due, Nawang bought his friend’s old running shoes – a pair of Kalenji from Decathlon. At the event in Leh, he participated in the half marathon and finished eighth. From 2015 onwards, he started getting podium finishes at the Ladakh Marathon; he opened his account with a second position in the half marathon in the open category. Archived results show his 2015 timing as 1:23:26.

A view of Lingshet (photo: courtesy Nawang Tsering)

That year he made his first trip to Mumbai as part of the team dispatched annually by Rimo Expeditions to participate in the Mumbai Marathon. Thereby, he got his first pair of new running shoes – a pair of Nike. In Mumbai, he trained under coach Savio D’Souza (Savio also visited Leh periodically to oversee his wards’ training). Contacted in mid-September 2023, after Nawang’s latest victory in Leh, the coach remembered the youngster he met in 2015 as a hardworking, good runner who was short on big race experience. Nawang’s first half marathon in Mumbai didn’t yield any podium finish. He found the heat and humidity challenging. But it was the beginning of a pattern in life – start the running season with the Ladakh Marathon in September and spend the winter months running the marathons of the plains with Rimo. In 2016, he successfully defended his second place in the half marathon in Leh and while he travelled with Rimo to Mumbai, Goa and Delhi and improved his timing, he could secure no podium finish anywhere outside of Ladakh.

Next year – 2017 – he became the winner (first place) of the half marathon in Leh with timing of 1:21:23 and followed that up with a second place in his age category at the Tata Steel 25K in Kolkata, his first podium finish outside Ladakh. However, his participation in the 2017 Airtel Delhi Half Marathon and the 2018 Mumbai Marathon yielded no podium finish, Nawang said. It was a spell of no encouraging results. Through the 2019 Tata Mumbai Marathon and the New Delhi Marathon, he continued to run the half marathon to no memorable finishes outside Ladakh. Barring exceptions, his timing in the half marathon was stuck in the range of 1:20 to 1:21. There were some near podium finishes but no real podium. His performance at home too, seemed unsteady. At the 2018 Ladakh Marathon, he completed the half marathon in 1:18:48 to secure first place. But in 2019, it was 1:22:34 and a third place on the podium. Then COVID-19 struck. The world slipped into pandemic and lockdown. Races were cancelled globally.

The intervening period till the resumption of races, was a period of reflection. Nawang had to figure out how to break free from entrapment in a plateauing half marathon performance and dearth of podium finishes. “ I was stuck in the 1:20 – 1:21 range,” Nawang said, portraying the frustration. It was from the consequent churn that the switch to the full marathon happened. Savio explained the logic and process. According to him, two angles counted. First, there were limitations in Ladakh to improving athletes’ speed because the required number of short distance races were not yet a major part of the region’s running ecosystem. Second, what runners like Nawang required was not merely speed but “ speed-endurance.’’ Or simply put, sustaining what speed they could whip up over a longer distance, which in turn helped them when running the the shorter distance races too. A kind of benign, synergic loop. “ For me, it was logical that Nawang should increase the distance of his long runs,’’ Savio said of the drift to full marathon. In his estimation (the whole thing viewed as developing speed-endurance), Nawang learning to be good at the marathon would have beneficial impact on his performance in the half marathon as well.

In Leh, Nawang did some of his training runs for the full marathon with Ladakh’s leading woman marathon runner, Jigmet Dolma (another of Savio’s Ladakhi students), and also with her fellow marathon runners, Tsetan Dolkar and Disket Dolma (they were all part of Rimo’s team). “ He did some of the easier runs with us. Beyond a point, our respective pace is different,’’ Jigmet said. In training, Nawang’s long runs typically touched 35 to 38 kilometres. “ In 2021, there was a marathon in Delhi. That is where I competed in the full marathon for the first time. I had timing of two hours, 42 minutes,’’ he said (the reference here is most likely to the 2021 New Delhi Marathon, where Nawang timed 2:42:49 to place sixth among men in the open category). The next event he recalled, was the 2022 New Delhi Marathon, where he got his personal best of 2:39:39. In September that year came his course record at the Ladakh Marathon.

Then the impact of the switch to full marathon, on the half, also manifested. At the 2022 Vedanta Half Marathon in Delhi, Nawang narrowly missed a podium position in his age category (in the half marathon) but gained a personal best of 1:14:45. In December 2022, he ran the Tata Steel 25K in Kolkata and placed third in the 18-24 years age group with timing of 1:31:28. Roughly a month later, at the 2023 Tata Mumbai Marathon, he placed fourth in the men’s 18-24 years age category of the full marathon with timing of two hours, 39 minutes, 49 seconds. What effect, better circumstances of training and being with runners of matching and superior ability can have on Nawang, is anyone’s guess.  

Going ahead, Nawang wishes to alternate between the full and half marathon. He plans to improve his timing. Many Ladakhi runners concede that while they have faith in their endurance, they find themselves challenged for speed in the races of India’s plains. Nawang trains as his coach, Savio, tells him to. He does his training runs, does free hand exercises and has generally avoided gyms. “ I have only one weight in my hostel room. Four kilos, that’s all,’’ Nawang said laughing. The bulk of his training is a composite of warm-up, running and stretching. Asked what he thought were essential to get closer to the timings reported at marathons elsewhere, he thought for a while and said: an improved diet, coach close by and perhaps access to some strength training. But what sets Nawang apart from the regular crop of Ladakhi runners is how he has imagined his life’s work.

Nawang crossing the finish line at the 2023 Ladakh Marathon (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Nawang currently holds a temporary job with the Ladakh Police. He also helps out at Rimo. Most male runners in Ladakh, once they become proficient in the sport, join the Ladakh Scouts or get picked up by this regiment of the Indian Army (the Scouts are known to treat their podium finishes at races in Ladakh as a regimental honour). According to Nawang, he was approached. But he held back for two important reasons. First, he is clear that whatever job he does should provide him room to train and grow further in running. It cannot be job above running; it should be a job that enables his future in running. To that extent, within the gamut of government jobs (including jobs in the military and paramilitary), he prefers establishments with a clear-cut sports quota and equally clear provisions for sportsperson to train. Second, he would like to contribute to running’s growth in Ladakh. “ I want to popularize running amongst my people,’’ he said. Outside the café, there was a quiet calm descended on Leh’s main market, also its much loved meeting spot; with the annual marathon over, the last flush of tourists to town had departed. Conversation completed, Nawang left for Lamdon.

“ Nawang Tsering is a star of Lamdon School. In fact, he is a Ladakh-star. He belongs to a very humble family. At an early stage itself, we saw his potential in long distance running. He has stayed on in the school hostel even after passing out. For Lamdon’s boarding school students, he is like an elder brother. He coaches and mentors students,” Dr Stanzin Dawa, principal, Lamdon Model Senior Secondary School, said when contacted. According to him, the Leh-based institution has its own imprint on the annual marathon with many who finish in the top ranks of the Ladakh Marathon’s various races, belonging to the school or its alumni.

The weekend after this writer met Nawang, it was the Sunday of the 6th Kargil International Marathon 2023. Nawang was due to run there. He did and secured the first place, covering the 42 kilometre-distance in a new personal best of 2:38:47 on September 17, 2023. That 2:39:39 from 2022, had become history. The union territory’s administration may need to put out a new press statement.

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai.)           

“ MY CONCLUSION IS THAT RUNNERS ARE TAKING ALTITUDE LIGHTLY”

Chewang Motup (right) and his wife, Yangdu, who together anchor the team hosting the annual Ladakh Marathon (photo: courtesy Motup)

Going into the annual Ladakh Marathon, Chewang Motup’s big worry had been the impact high altitude may have on those who arrived for the event’s races.

He kept reminding participants of the need to respect acclimatization protocols. As race director, he experiences the tension that nearly 6000 people congregating for the four day-event and the potential of non-Ladakhis in the fray acquiring altitude related illness, bring. The event’s races happen across altitudes spanning Leh’s 11,500 feet to the 17,618 feet of Khardung La, among the world’s highest motorable passes. As altitude rises, oxygen level in the atmosphere reduces making athletic performance tougher. In this context, the problems organizers face (as mentioned in an earlier article on this blog) are several. There are participants who don’t disclose pre-existing medical conditions, which could worsen at altitude. To get used to functioning at altitude, some days dedicated to the purpose, including rest therein, is essential. But there are those who think that protocols for acclimatization are unimportant and treat it lightly. As this writer noticed, runners arrive late and insist on getting bibs. Friends reached early try collecting bibs for those unable to reach Leh on time. It provokes arguments, for collection of bibs in person and on time are the primary means by which organizers stay convinced (to the extent possible) that protocols are being followed.

Making matters worse, there is no hesitation on the part of some runners in throwing their weight around. Position, status, importance of self – all these come into play even as organizers emphasize that the acclimatization protocols are in place to protect participants. Holding one’s ground against such negotiators is tough. Thanks to the safety measures the organizers must take and the lengthier duration of stay demanded (due to acclimatization protocols), the Ladakh Marathon is an expensive affair. Those who paid money and registered, try to ensure money’s worth. It reminds of an Everest expedition (albeit on a much smaller scale), where the hunger for achievement risks trumping reality. It will be so unless there is awareness and ownership among runners of what they are getting into. In other words, a race at high altitude is very dissimilar to a race in the plains.

Early morning, September 8, 2023: runners on the road to Khardung La; between North Pullu and the 17,618 feet-high pass (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Unlike events at low altitude, where laxity may be accommodated without any grave consequences to one’s health, at high altitude, poor acclimatization and subsequent ailments can result in death if medical intervention is not quick. There is thus a greater degree of responsibility expected on the part of participants, as regards events at high altitude. On the last day of the marathon expo (it is where racers collect their bibs), Motup was heard telling a participant pleading for relaxation of rules around bib collection, “ I am sorry, we are now very close to the race. I can’t give the bib to someone else and without seeing you in person. Don’t tell me how supremely fit you are or what your past record at races is. I have people working for me who climbed Everest multiple times. And yet, each of them has no option but to follow protocols when freshly coming to high altitude.’’ Besides being race director of Ladakh Marathon, Motup also owns Rimo Expeditions, one of the biggest adventure travel companies in India.

To complicate things, health problems experienced at high altitude are still a subject of study in medicine. Not only does each person seem to take differently to altitude but the same person needn’t have the same response to altitude, always. Even if protocols are met, things may go wrong depending on variables ranging from conditions on race day to the physical and mental state of a participant at that instance. While this can easily strengthen the lobby trivializing acclimatization protocols, fact is – all the precautions taken and safety measures met, matter in the analysis of a mishap. Documented evidence is vital. This is among reasons why race organizers insist on protocols being followed. This is why they feel beleaguered when runners argue on critical topics like protocols around acclimatization. “ My conclusion is that runners are taking altitude lightly,’’ Motup said.

The finish line of Silk Route Ultra and Khardung La Challenge, in Leh’s main market area (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Two days after the 2023 edition of the Ladakh Marathon had concluded, this writer met Motup for a post-race chat. The stress he had accumulated dealing with the event and its participants, was still only working its way off. As with previous editions (the event is now a decade old), the 2023 race witnessed no fatal incident on its course. In the run-up to the event, a lady who had come to run the half marathon collapsed at dinner and died, in Leh (11,500 feet elevation). In another incident, a runner who completed the half marathon in Leh, passed away after reaching home in Mumbai. Whether high altitude had any role to play in these unfortunate demises, we may never know. Ahead of the Silk Route Ultra-runners setting off for Kyagar (start line of the race), there was a session by a high-altitude medicine specialist, on the challenges of performing in such rarefied atmosphere. Including what distress calls from the body to stay alert for and when to call it quits. The session concluded with a moment of silence to pay respects to one of the departed. On race day, the two ultramarathons within the Ladakh Marathon fold (Silk Route Ultra and Khardung La Challenge, both of which touch heights exceeding 17,500 feet), witnessed a few worrisome incidents. Luckily, none were fatal. Ambulances were nearby and people could be evacuated in time. Besides ambulances on the ready, the Ladakh Marathon also keeps a helicopter on stand by for speedy medical intervention.

With roots in mountaineering, Motup looks at high altitude and performance at high altitude through eyes forged in that sport. He has been involved with numerous climbing expeditions (some of them research expeditions as well) and is currently the president of the prestigious Himalayan Club. Rimo Expeditions have been guides and providers of support for many high-altitude mountaineering expeditions, all along the Indian and Nepal Himalaya and that part of the Karakoram ranges which fall in India. Motup speaks from experience. For the 2024 edition of the Ladakh Marathon, he said that he would like to see runners showing greater respect for acclimatization protocols. There will be reduced room for any special considerations. Bibs may have to be collected in person, on time. On the race front, a degree of self-support – mainly the use of hydration packs – may be made compulsory in the two ultramarathons. Since the hosts must set an example themselves, Ladakhi ultrarunners, who have so far run the ultramarathons like an extended marathon, counting on aid stations for water and nutrition, may be told to start getting acquainted with hydration packs. The organizers may look to acquire chip-based tracking devices that allow them to monitor runners’ progress and act quickly if anyone is suspected to be in trouble. And in 2024, the tiered start of the Silk Route Ultra seen so far (in 2023, the elites commenced their run one and a half hours after the rest of the field had started) may be replaced by a single, consolidated start.

Shey; where the marathon sleeps (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Motup also explained why he doesn’t support the oft heard demand for relaxed stage cut-off in the Silk Route Ultra. At 122 km, plenty of uphill, the Khardung La pass to cross and stage cut-offs that continue to challenge despite being eased a bit in 2023, the Silk Route Ultra is a pretty difficult undertaking for any runner. As Motup pointed out, a longer stage cut off simply keeps a participant at high altitude for a longer period of time. Being at high altitude and straining there anyway damages the human body. At the same time, high altitude with its accompaniment of reduced oxygen level, is not apt ambiance for the body to heal. So, longer exposure to high altitude is simply an invitation to worsen matters. This is why it’s so much better to prepare well for the race at more hospitable altitudes, follow acclimatization protocols in Ladakh, take a reasonable shot at performing in the high-altitude race and not stay around for too long in the risky heights of the course. At this point, as a matter of fairness, it should be mentioned that race arrangements must also stay sensitive to the need for runners avoiding long stays in truly high portions of the course. In 2023, for instance, some runners told this blog of a lack of order and retrievability in how drop bags were stored at one of the really high aid stations. It caused a delay in locating bags. They wanted such details improved.

Shey; where the marathon sleeps (photo: Shyam G Menon)

Motup said that in his estimation, the presence of high altitude as its distinguishing feature, rendered the Ladakh Marathon an event with limited comparable brethren to consider for benchmark, when it came to deciding eligibility for participation. Elevation may be piled on by doing gradients at lower altitude but Ladakh’s high altitude (and its dry weather) or the altitude of Khardung La cannot be easily replicated. Finding exactly similar races to qualify for the races at Ladakh Marathon, is difficult. He said that over time, he may look to eligibility being decided by races within the Ladakh Marathon fold. Thus, performance at the Ladakh Marathon (42 km) may be used to decide eligibility for the Khardung La Challenge (72 km), which in turn may be treated as eligibility for the Silk Route Ultra (122 km). Motup found this reliable and safe to decide eligibility as these races are happening in the same overall high-altitude ecosystem and near similar sub-ecosystems.  “ I think someone doing the Khardung La Challenge in under 11 hours could be considered for the Silk Route Ultra. Someone completing KC in under 10 hours, even more so ‘’ he said. However, asked about trail races, Motup said that while he would love to see Ladakhi runners take on trail based-events elsewhere, hosting a trail race in Ladakh would be quite challenging as off-road medical and search and rescue capabilities in Ladakh are not as evolved as they are, overseas. For now, sticking to the road made sense.       

The evening of September 13, a day after the post-race chat with Motup, this writer beheld a large yard (owned by Rimo) in Shey village, where the Ladakh Marathon had come to hibernate till 2024. Hundreds of road dividers fabricated from metal arranged in rows, stacks of traffic cones, the metal framework of tables and arches and plenty of signages bore testimony to the groundwork the organizers had put in for over ten years. All, the physical infrastructure of a marathon; they basked in Ladakh’s evening sunshine, counting the days to another edition of India’s premier running festival at high altitude.         

(The author, Shyam G Menon, is a freelance journalist based in Mumbai.)